Why great workshops change so little, and what to do about it
“I don’t think training programs really work.”
I had barely sat down when the senior leader across the table said this. No small talk. He wanted me to know exactly where he stood.
I’m sure many of you have heard some version of this from a business stakeholder. The easy response is to file the person away as difficult, or a sceptic. Instead, I said something that I think surprised him.
“I agree with you. But can you tell me a bit more about why you feel that way?”
He smiled. Then he told me about the many “nice-sounding” training programs he had funded over the years, and how little any of them had changed.
Before you label me a traitor to the cause of L&D, let me explain. Our positioning line at FocusU is “We turn learning into behaviour change.” I believe in what learning can do when it’s done right. I also think that leader had a point.
We’ve spent fifteen years designing learning experiences. For a long time, whenever a program didn’t stick, I assumed the answer was better design and execution: more engaging content, more contextualisation, a more skilled facilitator. It took me far too long to see that the workshop was rarely the problem. The problem was everything around it.
Behaviour follows its environment
In 1936, the psychologist Kurt Lewin put forward an idea that has aged remarkably well: behaviour is a function of the person and their environment. Most corporate learning focuses almost entirely on the person. We build knowledge and skill, and then send people back into an environment that is set up, usually without anyone meaning it to be, to produce the old behaviour.
Take a new manager who has just finished a learning journey on coaching rather than telling. Back at the office, her boss wants to know why a deliverable is late and expects an answer in five minutes. Her team has learnt that the fastest way to get a decision is to escalate. The weekly review rewards people who have answers, not people who ask questions. So, she goes back to telling. She hasn’t failed to apply what she learnt. She’s responding logically to the system around her.
Four layers, one system
That is the thinking behind the FocusU Behaviour Stack. It describes four layers that shape how anyone behaves at work, each sitting inside the next.
The FocusU Behaviour Stack: behaviour nests inward, and each layer shapes the ones inside it.
- Individual: how a person thinks, communicates and acts. Skills, mindsets, daily habits. Most training lives here.
- Team: how people work together. Trust, how disagreement gets handled, how decisions are made and followed through.
- Leaders: what the people above pay attention to, reward and tolerate. People seldom behave better than the example set above them.
- Culture: the container. The rituals, structures, language and systems that make some behaviours feel normal and others feel risky.
Think of these as layers of influence rather than levels of seniority. A leader sits inside a team as well as above it. The outer layers aren’t more important than the inner ones, but they are stronger. In my experience, when the two pull in different directions, the outer layer wins almost every time.
Toyota is the example everyone reaches for, and for good reason. Any worker on the line can pull the andon cord when they spot a problem. That’s an individual act. But it only works because a team leader shows up within seconds to help, the team treats a stopped line as a problem to solve together, and the culture sees every pull as useful information rather than a failure. Teach the individual behaviour as a stand-alone, and nobody pulls the cord.
What breaks when you work on one or two layers
Individual only. We once ran a “Presenting with Impact” program for a client. Participants left with some powerful new ideas. They practised in the room and got feedback from the facilitator and from each other. Back at work, they slowly drifted into their old habits.
When people return from a learning experience, they have to answer two questions for themselves: “Can I?” and “Will I?” The first is about confidence in their own ability. The second depends on a lot more. In this case, the workplace simply didn’t feel safe enough to try something new. “It was too scary to try” was a line we heard more than once. This is the pattern I see most often, and feedback forms never pick it up.
Individual and team, without leaders. This one came from a two-day program on creative and innovative thinking. By the end of the workshop, individuals had picked up tools they could use back at work, and the team had agreed on a few team-level commitments. During the closing round, one participant asked, “Can you get our leaders to attend this workshop too?” There was nervous laughter around the room. It turned out that in this organisation, mistakes were frowned upon and stayed attached to people long after the event. Even if they now knew how to think creatively, trying an idea that might well fail felt like a career-limiting move. The stated need was “be more creative.” What everyone had actually learnt was “this is how things work around here.”
Leaders only. A leadership team came to an offsite wanting to arrive at new ways of working. It was a productive session, and they left with four of them. Back at work, these were announced through the Leader’s Desk, the CEO’s monthly internal note. A few leaders who had been in the room took the time to walk their teams through the whole thing, including how and why they had landed on those four. Many didn’t. The daily rush of work took over, and besides, the CEO’s note was self-explanatory. The new ways of working died a quiet death, and people filed them away as the flavour of the season. That kind of cynicism makes the next initiative harder to land.
Culture only. It began with a values workshop. The team came out with a new set of values that everyone agreed would make a difference. Then came a launch event, a refreshed intranet and, yes, posters everywhere. Six months later, I had a candid chat with the CHRO. The initiative had largely been shelved, even though the values were still on the walls. In the CHRO’s words: “People can recite the values, but I’m not sure they’re being lived the way we meant them to be.” Without leaders visibly acting on the values and teams building habits around them, reciting is about as far as it goes.
There’s one other kind of failure worth pondering over. Organisations that do invest at every layer often treat each piece as separate. The manager program is its own thing. So is the team offsite, and so is the values campaign. Each comes with its own language. The connections between the layers, which is where behaviour really gets reinforced, are either never considered or left to chance.
Work on one layer, design for all four
I want to be careful here, because this can sound like a pitch for bigger budgets. It isn’t. Most L&D teams can’t fund work at all four layers, and most behaviour problems don’t need it. The shift is smaller and more practical. Whichever layer you’re working on, design with the other three in mind. In practice, that usually comes down to three things.
- Before: brief the participants’ managers on the one behaviour to look for, and agree with sponsors on what they will stop doing that works against it.
- During: leave the room with a team-level ritual or working agreement, not only individual action plans.
- After: attach the new behaviour to a meeting, review or process that already exists, so nobody has to remember to do something extra.
What this looks like in practice
A few design stories from our work. I share them to show how this way of thinking works in practice.
A pharma giant’s operations team. The team worked with stakeholders across several geographies. What they asked us for was “a culture sensitivity program”, so that what one team said would be understood the way it was meant. That meant designing at both the individual and the team level, so the teams arrived at a shared way of working. Designed only for individuals, it would not have survived contact with the real world. The day ended with the team building a playbook of clear “if X happens, we will do Y” agreements.
A large Indian manufacturer. Two earlier innovation programs had delivered good content and very little change. So, we designed at the individual and team level, and also got the leaders to buy into the new methods. We kept the immersion, but spent as much design effort on what happened afterwards: a capture sheet for latent customer needs, a pocket card on the biases that shut ideas down, and a few simple lenses for looking at familiar situations afresh.
A global semiconductor equipment company. Its first-time managers were already going through a well-regarded curriculum from another provider. Our job was the bridge back to work. Through group and one-to-one coaching, we helped each manager name what was getting in the way. Was it skill, motivation, their own manager, or a process that made the right behaviour hard? That meant designing with all four layers in mind.
A large Indian services organisation, after a merger. New values had to land with people who differed in role, location and legacy company. That meant designing at the individual, team and leader levels. We turned each value into small, visible micro-actions and trained internal leaders to carry them, so the values travelled through leaders rather than memos and showed up in how individuals and teams worked.
Questions worth sitting with
- Think of your last program that scored well. What did participants’ managers do differently in the month that followed?
- If a participant applied the new behaviour perfectly next week, who around them would notice? Who would push back?
- Which existing meeting or review could carry the behaviour, so you don’t have to invent something new?
- What are your senior leaders currently tolerating that contradicts what your programs teach?
- Are you measuring the event, or the behaviour?
I think about that senior leader often. What he had lost faith in was learning that ended at the classroom door, and on that, I can’t argue with him.
If you’re shaping a program and want to test it against the four layers before it launches, we’d be glad to think it through with you. Let’s co-create learning that truly changes behaviour.