Stepping into a managerial role for the first time can be exciting – and overwhelming. As L&D professionals, HR leaders, and business heads, we know that what often makes or breaks a new manager’s success is not just intent, but how well they are supported in those crucial early months. That’s where thoughtfully designed leadership training comes in.
But with so many leadership programs, certifications, and coaching formats available, the challenge isn’t a lack of options. It’s picking the one that truly fits.
In our experience, choosing the right leadership course for new managers is less about trends and more about fitment – with your culture, your business goals, and the realities your managers face every day.
Here’s a comprehensive guide based on what we’ve seen work (and not work) across industries.
1. Start with Strategic Alignment
Table of Contents
Before evaluating a course structure or content, start with the why.
- What are the leadership behaviours your organization wants to build?
- What challenges do your new managers face most often – delegation? giving feedback? managing former peers?
- What business outcomes do you hope this program will influence?
A good program doesn’t just teach theory. It should tie directly to your organization’s purpose and performance priorities.
In our work with clients, we’ve noticed that the most impactful programs are those that mirror the organisation’s real-world rhythm and aspirations.
2. Look Beyond the Buzzwords – Prioritise Core Competencies
Most new managers are thrown into the deep end. The shift from individual contributor to people manager is not a linear one.
In our experience, the best programs cover these five core areas:
- Self-awareness and mindset shifts
- Communication and active listening
- Giving and receiving feedback
- Delegation and accountability
- Coaching and team development
These aren’t just training modules – they’re the muscle groups of management.
A well-structured program will layer these skills thoughtfully, with space for reflection and application.
Related Reading: Top Skills Every New Manager Should Learn
3. Prioritise Practical Application
Theory without practice is like learning to swim on dry land.
We’ve noticed that what truly helps new managers internalise concepts is:
- Simulations
- Role plays
- Real business scenarios
- Peer feedback
- Application tools like coaching journals or reflection trackers
An ideal program should replicate common workplace challenges and create space to practice before performing.
We’ve seen managers transform when they’re given safe spaces to fumble, reflect, and try again.
Related Reading: 5 Tips for New Managers
4. Insist on Customisation
A first-time manager at a start-up has a different reality than one in a manufacturing plant.
That’s why copy-paste programs rarely stick. Look for courses that:
- Use your company’s language and context
- Incorporate your values or leadership principles
- Allow for modular customization based on your audience
In our practice, every program we design begins with stakeholder interviews and needs assessment. This not only enriches content, but also builds internal buy-in.
5. Evaluate the Facilitators – Not Just the Content
Even the best content can fall flat if the delivery lacks depth.
We’ve found that experienced facilitators bring:
- Contextual stories from real-world leadership roles
- The ability to hold space for discomfort and dialogue
- A coaching mindset, not just a teaching style
Ask who will be facilitating the sessions. Check for alignment in tone, maturity, and credibility.
A good facilitator doesn’t just transfer knowledge – they spark insight.
6. Seek Continuity, Not One-Off Sessions
True leadership development is a journey, not a two-day workshop.
What has worked best in our experience is:
- A multi-session structure (e.g., once every two weeks)
- Time for workplace application between sessions
- Follow-ups through nudges, check-ins, or buddy systems
- Reflection tools or digital platforms for peer sharing
Look for programs that build in cadence. That’s what sustains the learning.
7. Think of Measurement Upfront
One common misstep is thinking about impact only at the end.
The right course should help you:
- Define learning success metrics
- Measure application (e.g., 360s, manager feedback, self-assessments)
- Track behavioral shifts, not just participation
We’ve noticed that even simple tools like manager feedback surveys or pre-post self assessments can generate valuable insights.
A Glimpse into FocusU’s New Manager Development Program
When we designed our own new manager development journeys, we distilled insights from years of facilitation and hundreds of client conversations.
Here’s how we approach it:
- Tailored Content: Based on role realities, stakeholder inputs, and business goals
- Experiential Structure: With real-time challenges, reflection spaces, and peer feedback
- Facilitators with Industry Credibility: Most of our facilitators have held senior roles across industries
- Reinforcement: Through check-ins, nudges, action planning, and digital tools
- Flexibility: Delivered virtually, in-person, or blended – based on your ecosystem
But beyond structure and format, what really sets the tone is intent. We don’t treat new managers as people to be fixed. We treat them as leaders in the making.
Related Reading: Building Leadership Skills for New Managers: A Comprehensive Guide
Final Takeaway: Choose the Course That Respects Your People
If there’s one thing we’ve learned over the years, it’s this:
The best training courses don’t overwhelm – they empower.
They meet people where they are. They build confidence. They demystify leadership. And most importantly, they create cultures where asking for help, giving feedback, and coaching teams becomes second nature.
As you choose your next leadership course for new managers, don’t just ask, “What’s included?” – ask, “What’s possible for my people?”
And if we can help you explore that journey, we’re always happy to have a conversation.
Related Reading: How to Ensure Learning Sticks: A Blended Approach for New Manager Development
