I remember staring at the whiteboard, completely blank. My team and I had been locked in a conference room for hours, trying to brainstorm a creative solution to a persistent customer problem. We were smart people. We had all the data. But every idea we generated felt… stale. Predictable. Boring. We were stuck in a loop, tracing the same tired thought patterns over and over again. We were suffering from a collective mental block, and the frustration in the room was palpable.
It felt like we were locked inside a box of our own making, unable to see the fresh perspectives that we desperately needed. We knew we needed to “think outside the box,” but we had no idea where the key was.
That evening, feeling defeated, I stumbled across an old book on my shelf: Roger von Oech’s classic, A Whack on the Side of the Head. I started flipping through it, and suddenly, my own mental block started to make sense. Von Oech’s core idea is simple but profound: our creativity is often hindered not by a lack of ideas, but by a series of self imposed “mental locks” that prevent us from exploring new possibilities. Reading that book felt like finding a master key. It did not just give me techniques; it gave me a new way to understand why I was stuck and how to break free.
The Problem: Why Our Brains Create “Mental Locks” That Block Creativity
Table of Contents
Our brains are efficiency machines. From childhood, we are trained to find the “right” answer quickly, follow the rules, be logical, and avoid ambiguity. These are essential skills for navigating daily life and executing tasks efficiently. However, the very processes that make us efficient also build walls around our thinking. They become mental locks that keep us trapped in familiar patterns and prevent us from accessing our natural creativity.
When faced with a novel or complex problem that requires a truly original solution, these locks become our biggest obstacle. We keep trying the same keys (our usual ways of thinking) on a lock that requires a completely different approach.
Introducing the Master Key: Roger von Oech’s A Whack on the Side of the Head
Von Oech’s genius was identifying these common mental locks and, more importantly, providing the playful, provocative “keys” needed to open them. His book is not a rigid process, but a collection of mental tools designed to jolt us out of our habitual thought patterns. It gives us permission to be illogical, impractical, and even a little bit foolish, because that is often where the most original ideas hide.
Unlocking Your Creativity: Tackling 5 Common Mental Locks
Let’s explore five of von Oech’s most powerful “locks” and the keys you can use to pick them when you feel creatively stuck at work.
Lock 1: “The Right Answer”
- The Lock: From school onwards, we are trained to believe that for every problem, there is one single “right” answer. This locks us into a convergent way of thinking, narrowing down possibilities too quickly and shutting off exploration.
- The Key: Embrace Ambiguity & Seek the Second Right Answer. When you find one solution, do not stop. Ask yourself, “Okay, that’s one way. What is another completely different approach?” Force yourself to generate multiple, diverse solutions before evaluating any of them. Use prompts like, “What if the opposite were true?”
Lock 2: “That’s Not Logical”
- The Lock: We often dismiss ideas that do not immediately make rational sense. We prioritize analytical thinking and suppress intuition, metaphor, and playfulness. This locks out a huge source of creative insight.
- The Key: Think Metaphorically. Metaphors are powerful tools for unlocking new perspectives. Ask, “What is this problem like?” Is building team morale like tending a garden? Is navigating a market shift like sailing in a storm? Exploring these seemingly illogical connections can reveal surprisingly practical insights.
Also read: SCAMPER: A Tool for Innovation
Lock 3: “Follow the Rules”
- The Lock: Rules and processes are essential for efficiency, but they can become rigid barriers to innovation. We get so used to “the way things are done” that we stop questioning if there is a better way.
- The Key: Challenge the Rules & Break Patterns. Make a list of all the rules (written and unwritten) surrounding the problem you are trying to solve. Then, ask for each rule: “What would happen if we deliberately broke this rule? What if we did the exact opposite?” Sometimes, the most innovative ideas come from intentionally breaking a long held assumption.
Lock 4: “Be Practical”
- The Lock: The moment a new idea emerges, our internal critic often jumps in with “That will never work,” “It’s too expensive,” or “It’s not feasible.” This premature practicality kills nascent ideas before they have a chance to grow.
- The Key: Ask “What If?” & Defer Judgment. During the idea generation phase, ban the phrase “Yes, but…” and replace it with “Yes, and…”. Allow impractical, even absurd, ideas to emerge without immediate judgment. Ask fantastical “What if?” questions. (“What if we had an unlimited budget?” “What if gravity did not apply?”) Sometimes, the seed of a practical breakthrough is hidden inside an initially impractical idea.
Also read: 11 Ways to Unleash Creativity and Innovation
Lock 5: “Avoid Ambiguity”
- The Lock: We crave clarity and certainty. Ambiguity feels uncomfortable, so we rush to find simple answers and shut down complex questions. This prevents us from exploring the nuances and paradoxes where true insights often lie.
- The Key: Embrace Paradox & Ask Better Questions. Instead of seeking immediate answers, learn to sit with ambiguous questions longer. Explore paradoxes. Can we be both low cost and high quality? Can we grow fast and maintain our culture? Holding these tensions, rather than resolving them too quickly, can spark more sophisticated and creative solutions.
The Leader’s Role: Giving Your Team Permission to Pick the Locks
These mental locks are often reinforced by our organizational culture. If the culture rewards only the “right” answer, punishes rule breaking, and demands immediate practicality, then creativity will wither, no matter how many brainstorming sessions you hold.
As a leader, your most important role is to create an environment where it feels safe for your team to pick these locks.
- Celebrate “Intelligent Failures”: When someone tries something new and it does not work, treat it as a valuable learning experience.
- Ask “What If?” Questions Yourself: Model the playful, impractical thinking you want to see.
- Protect Divergent Thinking Time: Create space for brainstorming where judgment is explicitly deferred.
You need to give your team the psychological safety to challenge assumptions, break patterns, and explore the unconventional.
Also read: How Leaders Can Foster Psychological Safety at Work
Your Keys Await
That frustrating brainstorming session was a gift in disguise. It forced me to recognize my own mental locks and rediscover the timeless wisdom in von Oech’s book. I learned that creativity is not a mystical talent; it is the result of intentionally challenging the assumptions that keep our thinking small.
The mental locks are real, but they are not permanent. You hold the keys. By recognizing your own habitual thought patterns and consciously choosing to apply these simple, powerful techniques, you can break free from your creative ruts and unlock a world of new possibilities. The next time you feel stuck, do not push harder. Just ask yourself: which lock am I caught in, and what key do I need to turn?
If you are looking to unlock the creative potential of your team and build a culture of innovation, explore FocusU’s workshops designed to challenge thinking and spark new ideas at FocusU.
